BBC screws British bloggers (again)
Over the past few years I have grown ever more incredulous about the way that the BBC has consistently stolen from, patronised and generally belittled blogs, especially British ones. There seems to be a pervading belief within Shepherd's Bush that the corporation is the British media and that the rest of the people who strive away working in commercial sectors are just basically there to do their research. Bloggers, as this post highlights, are beneath contempt and clearly don't have worthwhile opinions.
The latest example of this arrogance is this week's Panorama expose of the way in which some of Primark's suppliers were employing child labour to finish their very competitively priced garments. It was gritty Panorama stuff, highlighting an injustice and sparking a debate about the ethics of the fashion industry.
Yet while the programme highlighted low pay and child labour the programme makers seemed to have no ethical qualms about screwing British journalists.
Researchers from Panorama contacted the Catwalk Queen team (btw Catwalk Queen is the UK's most-read pure fashion website - compare it with Vogue, Cosmo and the others etc on Google Trends) and asked if they could film the team talking about why and how Primark had become so popular in the UK. The Panorama team then spent three hours filming at shiny offices, which basically cost Shiny nine hours worth of blogging.
The team's opinions were widely used throughout the show and in many ways their views held the piece together. However while every other single person on the show received a credit along with their work title (Mary Portas got a plug for her business, Yellowdoor, twice), the Catwalk team were not credited in any way. Instead only their names were used and they were billed as fashionistas or Primark fans.
The BBC also used some, admittedly fair low quality footage of the opening of Primark's store on Oxford Street, as well as some other CQ fashion reviews. However instead of crediting Shiny Media or Catwalk Queen it was billed as being courtesy of YouTube.
Basically the Catwalk team was featured on the programme because they are intelligent and articulate professionals who spend their life tracking high street fashion trends. They are also among the most popular fashion bloggers outside the US. To not credit them is not just incredibly condescending but also denies millions of viewers a chance to read their other opinions on fashion.
As for crediting the footage to YouTube, I'd like to see the Beeb use ITV's footage, some of which is on YouTube, on one of its programmes and then credit it to YouTube. In case the Panorama team is still confused - YouTube is a popular video hosting site - companies don't cede copyright of their footage the minute they put their video on the site.
Panorama could have made amends by placing a link to Catwalk Queen alongside quotes from the team on one of its web pages. Yet all it has done, after some serious nagging by the team, is to put a link to Catwalk Queen on the Primark debate page. There's no mention of the fact that it is the blog of the team that were featured so prominently in the programme.
The BBC, which in case you have forgotten is funded by all of us, should have a responsibility to work alongside and nurture young British media talent. Instead it seems to constantly patronise them.
As for Shiny I think the company should send the Panorama team an invoice for nine hours lost work.
Overall the whole episode has left a very bitter taste in the mouth at Shiny. While Panorama, and the rest of the BBC, should be praised for exposing dubious ethics in the fashion industry, it might want to take a look at its own ethical code once in a while too.
Ashley
Very good point Ashley - it's appalling they were not credited in any way, shape or form, and that it's yet another notch on the wall of unethical actions undertaken by the Beeb.
Well said Ashley. The beeb should know better!
I send invoices and they pay.
Feeling your pain - not the first time, though, that a media co has swept in for footage only to claim that it doesn't quite fit with their production whim of the moment...
Grrr to the Beeb.
Sorry to hear they screwed you lovely Shiny Media :(
How does the closing statement suggest bloggers are beneath contempt and don't have worthwhile opinions?
He wrote: "So if you want to find out what they asked him and what he told them, keep an eye on the bloggers."
Read bloggers he closed with. But maybe only those who can struggle to the end of posts.
Hi Gordon
It is just the rather condescending tone of the piece that I object to.
Btw I got this from Sandy Smith, editor of Panorama and I am very grateful he has apologised.
"Hi, I'm the editor of Panorama. Looking back we should have given the girls an onscreen credit as well because their contribution was excellent. This was overlooked in the final stages of a long and complicated investigation. Panorama has a new multiplatform editor, a bigger and better website on the way precisely because we recognise the new talent and opportunities out there. Didn't get it right this time, sorry to all at Shiny and Catwalk Queen".
I hope you're going to contact the Beeb and complain.
Hi, I'm the editor of Panorama. Looking back we should have given the girls an onscreen credit as well because their contribution was excellent. This was overlooked in the final stages of a long and complicated investigation. Panorama has a new multiplatform editor, a bigger and better website on the way precisely because we recognise the new talent and opportunities out there. Didn't get it right this time, sorry to all at Shiny and Catwalk Queen.
Although it might have been an oversight there is still an 'us and them' attitude amongst many journalist who work within MSM.
Recently the BBC covered the story of a man who was stopped at Heathrow Airport for wearing a Transformers t-shirt where one of the characters was holding a gun.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/london/7431640.stm
Aside from the stupidity of the airport authorities the article featured a link to BAA, but didn't link to the site of Brad Jayakody the guy concerned and who naturally wrote all about the story.
http://www.theedgeofmadness.com/index.php?title=no_t_shirt_no_flight
Hopefully attitudes will change as more journalists use blogs as both a tool and a source.
Interesting. Especially since a journalist at the BBC once told me they used Shiny blogs every day to source stories!
Just saw the link to my blog in my referrals.
I'm the guy who who's blog you're talking about (yes the one with the t-shirt).
The BBC contacted me and asked to do a story with me. They interviewed me separately for that piece (both online and for the tv news).
For that incident, "The Sun" and "BBC" both contacted me directly and did an interview, getting my permission to do so.
Here's the quick blog post I did about the BBC interview when it happened.
http://www.theedgeofmadness.com/index.php?title=more_t_shirt_stuff
I'm completely unfussed about being linked back. My blog is a personal blog, and in the 5 odd years I had it before this story, I made all of 10 cents from it.
Watched the documentary and never knew the involvement of Catwalk Queen and Shiny Media until reading this post. Glad you've battled through and got your credit, all be it sadly to the people who venture on to these pages.
I guess the same can be said about Radio 1 who use Perez Hilton. Why not something British like hecklerspray, Holy Moly or Popbitch? Whilst those sites are very popular, they aren't as big as Hiltons site. But to be fair, they have not become a parody of what they set to do: Report on celebrity folk being idiots and becoming one themself like Hilton has done.
Quite right Ashley - bbc (and others) are just plagiarising
Thanks for sharing so significative article with us. I agree with your idea competely.
Hi, the article is so wonderful, I am interested in it. I will pay attention to your articles.
This is a really good read for me. Must agree that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw. Thanks for posting this informative article.
Tods is an Italian brand, shoes, covering appurtenances and added affairs articles articles and chaired by agent Diego Della Valle. Synonymous with acceptable above and Italian style, makes the Tod's products, the alluringly simple and affably practical. The cast craftsmen plan with the world's a lot of comfortable covering and anniversary section has the incomparable attending and feel can "truly handmade.
good article,I’m positive my followers will find this article really useful.
Thanks for you very great post which are very useful for me, we suppy the best r4 card, if you are interesting, please go to have a look.
It's always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I'm sure you had fun writing this article.
Nice review. I think this write up was actually a great beginning to a potential series of write ups about this topic.
True Religion Outlet
The Texans had been clear favorites against Oakland, yet somehow they managed to pull out the win, just a day after the team's iconic owner, Al Davis, passed away at the age of 82.Going into the game, I felt the passing of Davis would either be so draining on the team that they would make many mistakes, or they would turn their emotion into a Raiders win.
Hi, the article is so wonderful, I am interested in it. I will pay attention to your articles.
Thank you for your articles
grossiste en ligne gros des produits chinois,boutique en ligne chinoise - Myefox.Thank you for your article.
Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!
cheap purse, cheap handbag, wholesale wallets, cheap luggages,
cheap backpacks and cheap sunglasses
Coach outlet
ugg outlet
wallets, cheap luggages,
cheap backpacks and cheap sunglasses
Search our site and and begin saving on Backes #42 St. Louis Blues jerseys at nfljerseyfactory.com
with 6 years of wholesale experience, we are 24 hours online service. its easy to work with and offer a full money back guarantee on the quality
of each display.
Thanks for sharing this post with me.
I like this article. its so nice.You’ve got style, class, bravado. I mean it. Please keep it up because without the internet is definitely lacking in intelligence.
our goal is to be popular and fashionable vane,offer the best products and service, the most preferential price.
his is my shop online, you can go on, please give me some opinion, all products are wholesale, if you like, you can order it!.
The cast craftsmen plan with the world's a lot of comfortable covering and anniversary section has the incomparable attending and feel can "truly handmade.
are yet to make up their mind about the kind of
shoes that they would be wearing, then the best
good quantily for you to choose
CFLL5GC5NFJR6PFENL
Comfortable more than stylish, sheepskin ugg footwear caters to globally men and women in today's era
Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information!
Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information!
good article, hope not the last one!i look forward the next one!
What a great article.So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject.
good posts
The cast craftsmen plan with the world's a lot of comfortable covering and anniversary section has the incomparable attending and feel can "truly handmade.
We Sale Cheap Jerseys ,Buy Cheap NFL Jerseys, MLB Jerseys, NBA Jerseys,NHL Jerseys Wholesale From USA Authentic Quality.
We Sale Cheap Jerseys ,Buy Cheap NFL Jerseys, MLB Jerseys, NBA Jerseys,NHL Jerseys Wholesale From USA Authentic Quality.
The Art of Wedding Dress, Bridal Gowns, Bridesmaid Dresses Designer At LuckyDresses.com
Thanks for sharing the the valuable conversation with us,it's useful for us.
wow,so cool!Keep up the excellent quality writing, it's uncommon to see a nice blog like this one nowadays.
This is a incredible blog,it's so nice.
I had been reading some of the actual posts right here,thanks!
Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!I'm still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post thanks.
www.fanbullet.com sells very real facebook fans and likes that will certainly like your products and are most likely to be turned as your customers. Traffic in this way will be huge, as many of those who are connected with your facebook fans will also visit your site.
I cannot thank you that you have produce what a great post that you have produce right here,so thanks!
what a fun post.I’d like to be the practitioner of this blog and as a honest fan about it.
Thank your for the article which is great I think.
I came accross your blog recently and have been reading along,it's so interesting.
I am so glad to reading this interesting blog,thanks!
This post really opened my eyes.
it is interesting and informative article.
Great article and it’s so helpful.
I have to thank you for this nice post,it's useful for me.
I am looking forward to see your another wonderful article,thanks!
I am so happy to fine so many useful information in this post.
Wind, blown crystal snowflake Solitude, tods shoes uk,tods shoes uk bleak memory, because you and warm. Merry Christmas.
Thanks for an idea, you sparked at thought from a perspective I hadn't thought of before . Now lets see if I can do something productive with it.